Is Organic Sugar Healthier than Regular One?

Published March 18, 2024

Organic products are supposed to be better for our health and the planet, but I am not sure how to feel about organic sugar.

When I see a product labeled "Organic Sugar," I cannot help but think about tobacco. If it were tobacco instead of sugar being labeled organic, how would this translate to our health?

Organic sugar, whether from sugar cane or beet, must adhere to strict guidelines that focus on sustainable farming practices, the non-use of synthetic fertilizers and pesticides, and maintaining ecological balance. Here are the general requirements for sugar cane or beet to be considered organic:

  • Non-GMO: The sugar cane or beet seeds must be non-genetically modified organisms (GMOs).
  • No Synthetic Chemicals: Organic sugar farming prohibits the use of synthetic fertilizers, pesticides, herbicides, and fungicides. Natural alternatives must be used to manage pests and fertilize crops.
  • Soil Health: Farmers must implement practices that promote healthy soil, such as crop rotation, cover cropping, and composting. The goal is to enhance soil fertility naturally and sustain soil health over time.
  • Water Management: Efficient water use and conservation practices are crucial in organic farming. Farmers must strive to minimize water usage and prevent water contamination.
  • Biodiversity: Organic farming practices encourage biodiversity. This includes maintaining a variety of crops and natural vegetation areas to support a diverse ecosystem.
  • No Artificial Additives: During processing, organic sugar must be free from artificial additives and processing aids. Any substance used in processing must meet organic standards.
  • Certification: To be labeled as organic, sugar cane or beet must be grown on farms that are certified organic by an accredited certification body. This involves rigorous inspections and adherence to organic farming standards set by governing bodies, such as the USDA in the United States or equivalent organizations in other countries.
  • Sustainable Farming Practices: Organic farming emphasizes sustainable practices that aim to reduce carbon footprint and environmental impact. This can include measures to reduce energy consumption, enhance wildlife habitats, and prevent soil erosion.

Conclusion

I believe organic products are a step in the right direction towards sustainability and health improvement. I also applaud the great effort producers have to make to get their products certified. However, I honestly don't like the use of the organic label as an implication that the product's content is healthier. To me, organic sugar is absurd in the same way I think organic tobacco is an oxymoron. Organic sugar might have a lesser environmental impact and contain fewer pesticides, but it still consists of empty calories my body does not need.

Share this page